How to Know If You Need a New Car Starter

by Jody L. Campbell

The starting and charging system on vehicles can be tricky to diagnose. The battery has to put out enough amperage to turn the starter solenoid. The starter solenoid needs to turn the flywheel and the plunger to disengage once the engine cranks over. The alternator needs to replace the spent voltage the battery expelled to engage the starter. Bad connections, corroded wires or failed components can all lead to a no-start situation. But there is a way to tell if it's the battery, alternator or the starter.

Open the hood and place a voltmeter onto the battery.
1

Open the hood to the car and place a voltmeter onto the battery. Place the red positive lead to the positive battery terminal indicated by the + insignia stamped on the battery case. Place the negative lead of the voltmeter onto the negative battery terminal indicated by the - insignia stamped on the battery case. If the voltmeter indicates 12.4 volts or less, recharge or replace the battery before proceeding.

Inspect the battery terminal clamps for corrosion or looseness.
2

Inspect the battery terminal clamps for corrosion or looseness. Clean the terminals if necessary—but before disconnecting, place a memory saver into the power source outlet inside the vehicle.

Use a hand wrench to loosen the battery terminal clamps and then remove them.
3

Use a hand wrench to loosen the batter terminal clamps and then remove them. Clean the terminals with a terminal cleaner and wire brush. Replace and tighten the terminals.

Have an assistant turn the ignition key.
4

Have an assistant turn the ignition key. Determine if there is a clicking sound when the ignition key is engaged and locate the component under the hood (or vehicle) making the noise. If the starter is making the clicking noise, check the wires connected to it for corrosion and looseness.

Use a hand wrench to loosen the retaining nuts holding the wire connections to the starter motor.
5

Use a hand wrench to loosen the retaining nuts holding the wire connections to the starter motor. Clean the blades of the connections with a wire brush and then reattach.

Turn the ignition key.
6

Have the assistant turn the ignition key. If a no-start or audible clicking is still present, have the assistant disengage the ignition key and turn on the headlights. Have the assistant engage the ignition key again while you look at the headlights. If they remain steady without dimming, the starter is most likely bad. If they dim low, the battery is most likely the culprit.

Remove your starter and get it tested.
7

Remove the starter and bring it to an auto parts store to have it bench tested if the battery passed the headlight test. If the starter cannot be rebuilt, you'll need to replace it.

Tip

  • check When the alternator fails in a vehicle, the red battery light will illuminate on the dashboard of the vehicle. Once the alternator can no longer replace the needed voltage back to the battery to keep it charged under operation, any and all electrical demand will literally suck the life from the battery until it no longer can provide charge for the vehicle. The engine will then die once it has drained the battery.

Items you will need

About the Author

Jody L. Campbell spent over 15 years as both a manager and an under-car specialist in the automotive repair industry. Prior to that, he managed two different restaurants for over 15 years. Campbell began his professional writing career in 2004 with the publication of his first book.

Photo Credits

  • photo_camera diego cervo/iStock/Getty Images