Pros and Cons of a Manual Transmissionby Shelley MooreUpdated July 25, 2023
The automotive world today is overwhelmingly dominated by automatic transmission cars, accounting for approximately 90% of vehicles on the road according to Progressive Casualty Insurance Company. Despite this, there's a group of drivers who stand by manual transmission vehicles, even amidst the increasing popularity of their automatic counterparts. While manual transmissions have their unique positives, several cons lead many consumers to prefer automatic vehicles.
Con: Practicality and Learning Curve
Driving a stick shift demands a learning curve that's typically steeper for new drivers compared to automatic cars. The driver needs to manually change gears using the clutch pedal, particularly in heavy traffic scenarios, which can be a significant inconvenience. Learning to drive a manual car, handling the steering wheel, and the timing of gear shifts can be challenging for first-time drivers, with stalling often a part of the experience.
Con: Challenging Driving Conditions
Manual transmission cars require a certain degree of skill, especially in challenging driving conditions. For instance, stopping at a red light on a steep incline amid heavy traffic can make even the most devoted stick shift fan yearn for an automatic transmission car.
Pro: Initial Cost and Anti-theft
The purchase price of a new car with a manual transmission, whether it's a Toyota or a Honda, is generally less than its automatic counterpart. Plus, manual transmission cars, being less common, are sometimes considered less attractive to car thieves, which can impact car insurance costs.
Pro: Maintenance Costs
Manual transmission vehicles typically have lower maintenance costs. They're easier on the brakes, and the transmission fluid requires fewer changes. Also, when a standard transmission encounters issues, the clutch is usually the culprit, which is less expensive to replace compared to the torque converter in an automatic car.
Pro: Control and Driving Experience
Manual transmission offers an unparalleled driving experience. Drivers of sports cars often prefer them as they're considered more 'fun to drive,' offering better control and faster response during gear shifts. This becomes a significant advantage in adverse weather conditions.
Historically, manual transmission was associated with better fuel economy. However, advancements in technology have seen the gap in fuel efficiency (MPG) shrink, with some automatic vehicles, especially those equipped with a continuously variable transmission (CVT) or dual-clutch, now offering comparable or even better fuel economy.
While the debate of 'manual vs automatic' continues, it's essential to understand that the choice between these two types of transmission will depend on various factors. These include the driving conditions you'll be facing, the experience of the driver, and personal preferences. When buying a used car, for instance, considerations such as maintenance costs and the vehicle's condition take center stage. It's also worth noting that automatic cars nowadays come with an array of automatic gearboxes, each offering different driving experiences and efficiencies. Hence, automatic vs manual is no longer a binary choice. It's about finding the right balance that suits your driving style and needs.
Shelley Moore is a journalist and award-winning short-story writer. She specializes in writing about personal development, health, careers and personal finance. Moore has been published in "Family Circle" magazine and the "Milwaukee Sentinel" newspaper, along with numerous other national and regional magazines, daily and weekly newspapers and corporate publications. She has a Bachelor of Science in psychology.